Macross 1/72

VF-1A/S Valkyrie

Kit Review

Straight build + light panel lining + seals

1. The slim, tightly packed proportions of Fighter mode are simply outstanding. The intricate underside layout is genuinely impressive.
2. The gimmick where the legs naturally spread apart in Gerwalk mode is also excellent.
3. The front/rear landing gear and covers are all fully articulated — absolutely top-notch. Stability both open and closed is superb.
4. The gimmick where the hands retract into the forearms in Fighter mode is also very well executed.
5. When folding the wings, the wing length is reduced further, making the Battroid's back more compact.
6. The transformation sequence where the nose shortens and the cockpit cover stored inside is pulled out and snapped into place is impressively precise — gives you goosebumps.
7. The knee/ankle length extension gimmicks are effective and hold well. The reverse-jointed legs in Gerwalk mode are properly represented too.
8. I never expected the Battroid to have a rotating waist joint — what a pleasant surprise!
9. The panel lines and detail work are refined and clean.
10. Excellent parts breakdown and high-quality seals mean the color combination looks great even as a straight build.

Cons

1. So much focus went into Fighter mode and the transformation gimmick that the Battroid's proportions ended up looking off...
2. The front-to-back body panel connection in Battroid mode is absolutely terrible. Just baffling.
3. The hip joint gimmick in Battroid mode also falls apart constantly unless you glue it in place... Worst hip joints in history. OTL
4. The articulated fingers come off way too easily and aren't durable at all. (I imagine this has sent a lot of people's rage meters through the roof.)
5. Assembly difficulty is high, and the transformation process is just as complex and tricky. (You'll be scared to transform it for fear of breaking something.)
6. Without panel lining, it looks pretty bare.
7. For a snap-fit kit, it feels a bit flimsy. Gluing certain sections for durability seems pretty much essential.

----------

The full details are covered one by one in the nearly 200 review photos, so please refer to the main review body for more.

This was a kit I had incredibly high hopes for, and it ended up being one that brings mixed emotions. The transformation gimmick in particular really lets you feel the anguish the designer must have gone through. It's no exaggeration to say this represents the pinnacle of aircraft-to-robot transformation engineering. It's truly the result of countless trials and errors, precise CAD design, and sheer developer dedication.

The problem is that most of the strengths are concentrated in Fighter mode and Gerwalk mode. The proportions in aircraft form are genuinely breathtaking, and Gerwalk is also really satisfying in terms of proportions... but Battroid feels like all the recessive genes got lumped together T_T

It seems like so much focus went into achieving those slim Fighter mode proportions that the arms ended up thin, the chest plate overly wide, the head awkwardly large — the Battroid mode proportions are going to be very divisive. But even more serious than the proportion issues is the stability problem in Battroid mode...

First, the front-to-back body panel connection is so hopelessly bad that you start wondering if this is really a Bandai kit. It's hard to understand how Bandai could have left the body held together so poorly. And the hip joints — which use a detach-and-reattach system as an unavoidable compromise for the full transformation — I get why they went with that design, but they're going to go down as the most absurd hip joints in the history of mecha plastic models T_T. At first they hold together a little, but after a few times pulling them apart and putting them back, they go completely loose. Unless you glue them permanently, the body and legs just keep falling apart — you can't even pose it, let alone just stand it up straight.

If I were to give grades by mode... Fighter gets an A+, Gerwalk gets an A, Battroid gets a D− That's about where I'd put them.

In the end, this feels like a kit that got so caught up in the ambition to achieve a perfect transformation gimmick that it dropped the ball in several other areas. It delivers the most sophisticated transformation gimmick ever seen in a kit, yet it's also the kit with the worst overall quality balance in history.

In a way, it almost feels like a transforming kit made by Hasegawa — precise engineering, but without the know-how for transformation mechanics and stability that comes from experience with mecha models. If you're a Gunpla fan used to the well-balanced feel of MG kits, this will probably feel a bit alien. (You might find yourself thinking, "Is this really a Bandai kit?") It might be slightly more intricate than the Gunpla lineup led by Katoki Hajime, but compared to Gunpla's baseline durability, this thing feels fragile and unreliable...

Ultimately, the Battroid is so flimsy that taking each photo was genuinely painful — the review process itself felt like a pilgrimage of suffering — making this a kit I'd be scared to build and review again. It's worth building once, and there's a real sense of meaning and accomplishment in it... but it's the kind of kit you never want to build a second time. Kind of like military service, if you know what I mean.

Despite its many strengths, a few of the flaws are just too serious to leave a clean aftertaste. That said, if you go in mentally prepared and focus on enjoying the precision of the gimmick, it can be a genuinely fun and rewarding build. I'm hoping a revised version will eventually come out to fix at least the woefully flimsy Battroid body and hip joint connections... Either way, this is going to be a renewal that sparks debate for years to come — a "historic" kit in one way or another. :-)

1/72 VF-1A/S Valkyrie | 2013.6 | ¥4,500

AIThis page was translated by Claude Sonnet.