Following the MG Zaku, the Gelgoog has arrived. And of course, the first one out of the gate is Char's Gelgoog. The overall concept is very similar to the MG Zaku — it's a kit where bold, ambitious ideas and technical limitations exist side by side. When it first came out, a lot of people were blown away by the incredible proportions. Refined proportions on a completely different level from the old kit, and a massive frame that towers over the Zaku! A big box, big parts, a more detailed and elaborate inner frame, and so on.
But looking at it now by 2005 standards as I update this review, it's a kit that sometimes gets listed as one of the worst MGs ever — a real tragic case. The reason is the articulation and joint strength. The terrible articulation alone is forgivable, but every single joint from head to toe was loose without exception, making it nearly impossible to hold any kind of pose. A wobbling waist, legs that dangle like jelly, loose knees and ankles, shoulders and forearms that droop the moment you raise them, fingers that can barely grip a rifle... it was pretty much a panic situation.
So a lot of people ended up reinforcing the joints with super glue and putty, which does work to a reasonable degree. Since the main cause is insufficient polycap tolerance, you can apply super glue (CA glue) to the plastic pegs and ball joints that fit into the polycaps, build them up, and let them harden to tighten the play. Of course, the Gelgoog also has some quirky structural issues with its joint design, so it's not a perfect fix — but it does make things noticeably less floppy.
That said, there must have been a lot of complaints about the Gelgoog's ultra-noodle joints right from the start, because it seems like there was a revision at some point. Since I'd mostly been buying first-run copies up until now, it was hard to confirm whether any changes had been made... but when I built what appears to be a more recently reprinted Gelgoog, the polycap tolerance had clearly improved to some degree. The joints that used to be absurdly loose had gotten better to the point where they weren't flopping around quite so badly. The problem is, I have no idea exactly when this revision happened (-_-;)r
In the end, buying an MG Gelgoog might come down to luck of the draw. Or you could go to a physical store rather than buying online and carefully check the import date — though even that's not a reliable method, since it's just the import date and the stock could have been sitting in a warehouse over there for a while. Otherwise, you can just go in with no expectations and plan to do a quick super glue fix to get it into reasonable shape. And honestly, even the revised version — while much better than the first run — isn't rock solid, just a bit less floppy. Either way, joint strength is always going to be the issue that comes up whenever anyone talks about the Gelgoog...
Setting aside the joint strength issues, the Gelgoog is actually a pretty great kit. For the price, you get a very large frame, a more elaborate inner frame, and impressive proportions that look genuinely imposing just standing there on display. The large, cool-looking shield and beam saber unit are well-realized. Compared to the MG Zaku in particular, a lot of effort went into hiding seam lines on this kit. From the shoulders, arms, and legs to the feet and skirt — lots of single-piece parts were used to keep seam lines nearly invisible. The molded color is also quite nice, showing noticeably better color quality than Char's Zaku. Of course, there are those who point out that the proportions feel quite different from the original design — the criticism being that it's been refined into something too sleek and modern.
So a lot of people go in with low expectations given all the bad press, but then actually see the Gelgoog in person and think "oh hey, this thing's actually pretty cool~". The sheer size, the smooth surfaces with no seam lines, the great molded color, the sharp proportions... then they start handling it and get a little disappointed again (^^;), but either way, it's genuinely a great display model.
It's also clearly a kit where the developers' passion shines through, following the MG Zaku. (Despite being an older kit,) the remarkable attention paid to seam lines, the frame and verniers, the use of mesh pipe, the optional detail-up parts — this kit is packed with the craftsmanship of the early MG developers. The only problem is that the technology of the time didn't allow it to reach its full potential in terms of quality, but the kit itself is genuinely excellent. For ¥3000, the box is also surprisingly huge — it'll catch you off guard the first time you see it ^^;
The joints are still a nagging concern with this kit, but there's no denying it's a landmark MG — the Gelgoog. If you go in without high expectations for the joints (or are prepared to do some fixes), it's actually a pretty great kit. If you've been on the fence, trust your luck and just go for it!! ^^;
- Footnotes -
The Char's Gelgoog I built doesn't appear to be a true first-run release.
According to information from Zakurer, the very first release was missing several things, and the version shown in this review is already a partially revised one. There were multiple revisions following complaints from many modelers, and the changes from the first release are listed below. Either way, this MG sure has had quite a story and a rocky road~
- Added molding inside the leg armor
- Added cover armor for the crotch area
- Added mechanical frame parts inside the shoulders
If you happen to have a first-run copy missing all three of the above, that's a genuine rare item. :-)
| Category | Rating | Analysis |
| Seam Lines | ★★★★☆ | Seam lines are handled quite well. Only slightly visible on the head and torso. |
| Molding Color / Color Separation | ★★★★☆ | Color separation is nearly perfect. Molded colors look really good. |
| Proportions | ★★★★☆ | Strike a pose and it looks absolutely stunning. Large-sized even among MGs. |
| Articulation | ★ | Worst articulation among MGs; |
| Joint Strength | ★ | Worst joint strength among MGs; though a revised version does exist. |
| Internal Frame | ★★★☆ | Frame covers a relatively large number of areas. The leg frame and pipes are great! |
| Detail | ★★★★ | External detail is nice, but the frame is a bit plain. |
| Weapons / Accessories | ★★★★ | All the weapons you'd expect for a Gelgoog are included. Looks very well-stocked. |
| Parts Count / Price | ★★★★ | 234 parts total (+ 24 detail-up parts). Parts per ¥1,000: 78 |
| Uniqueness | ★★★★ | Despite the worst articulation and joint strength among MGs — the Gelgoog still looks great just standing there on display. |
| Dalong's Point : 70 pts. |
MG Char's Gelgoog | 1996.12 | ¥3,000
AIThis page was translated by Claude Sonnet.